Every single day of the weeks-long trial, the family has sat together in the courtroom in a show of support for the disgraced attorney. It blew me away that Im sitting here showing them where Maggies phone is and they dont take the time to walk with me or to take this phone and go find it, he said. John Marvin testified his friend told him the crime scene was cleared, and he decided to visit. What you might have missed over the weekend, Hampton law firm says Alex Murdaugh misappropriated money, was forced to resign, Alex Murdaugh resigning from family law firm, entering rehab after shooting, Alex Murdaugh called 911 after being shot in the head Saturday in Hampton County, SLED says, Alex Murdaugh, dad and husband of murder victims, shot in head in Hampton Co., lawyer says. Goude asked how that would be possible without the shooter also leaving their own bloody footprints inside the feed room. He way the one who removed the boat from the water after the fatal crash involving Paul. The white T-shirt was just one piece of evidence John Marvin called into question. The Murdaugh murder trial began on January 23 of this year, and Alex's younger brother took to the stand and testified for the defense that he was the one who cleaned up Paul's remains at the gruesome murder scene, saying it was "the hardest thing" he ever had to do. Defense attorney Dick Harpootlian has ended his examination of Dr. Jonathan Eisenstat, a forensic pathologist called to testify as a defense witness. Judge Clifton Newman will gavel court back in Monday morning, after the 12-member jury listened to the former Lowcountry attorney testify in his own double-murder trial for hours Thursday and Friday. I would stop, crying for a moment, just in disbelief.. He also admitted to years of opioid abuse and to lying to investigators about whether he was at the dog kennels with his wife, Maggie, and youngest son, Paul, before they were murdered. Defense expert says height unrealistic to have killed Maggie, Day 21: Murdaughs defense revives two-shooter theory as forensic expert takes the stand, Murdaughs defense begins effort to undermine case for Lowcountry attorneys guilt, Car data mapped Alex Murdaughs movements the night of the murders. Alligator living at Walmart in NC stirs debate, as many demand it be allowed to stay, 2 popular chain restaurants get B grades: Triangle sanitation scores (Feb. 28). He also testified that a SLED agent told him they had recovered a coat from somewhere in the back of his parents property at Almeda. Video, captured by Live 5 News, showed the younger Murdaugh brother walking past a man holding a sign outside the courthouse which read: Justice Coming Soon. Dueling arguments face off in Murdaugh trial opener, Watch: Attorneys make opening statements in Alex Murdaughs trial, Who is Clifton Newman? Attorneys said at the bond hearing that they were nearing a resolution with Alex Murdaugh and that he had Lead prosecutor Creighton Waters said this morning the state has around four witnesses they plan to bring to the stand. But, when he approached law enforcement and showed them, he testified that they brushed it off, saying they had technology coming later to help find it. Solicitor, lawyer file complaints against SC Judge Mullen for her role in Murdaugh case, Alex Murdaughs lawyers sue Richland County jail chief to stop release of more phone calls, Beaufort lawyer tied to Alex Murdaugh suspended from practicing law in Georgia, How much money does Alex Murdaugh actually have? Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand. He agreed with the defenses contention that Paul often would leave his guns in various locations. The Murdaugh family saga has dominated the news after another shooting, a resignation and criminal accusations with Alex Murdaugh at the center of it all. Heres what SLED chief says, Financial firm denies involvement with Alex Murdaugh in housekeeper settlement, Passenger sues Alex Murdaugh, gas station over injuries from 2019 fatal boat crash, SC lawyer says hes found the missing order in $4.3M ex-Murdaugh nanny insurance case, Photos, video show shackled Alex Murdaughs first SC court appearance, SC judge grants Alex Murdaugh bond in case stemming from failed suicide plot, Alex Murdaugh arrested for allegedly staging his own SC murder for insurance money, Whos who? From left, Randy Murdaugh; John Marvin Murdaugh; his wife, Liz Murdaugh; Brooklynn White; and Buster Murdaugh, the son of Alex Murdaugh, leave the courthouse for lunch. He currently lives in Okatie, South Carolina with his wife Li,z and their three children. John Marvin said he felt the urge to take care of the rest of Paul Murdaughs remains, and start cleaning the room. Alex Murdaughs brother testified Monday to instances when he believed law enforcement was trying to mislead him about their investigation into Murdaughs role in the murders of his wife and son. SLED charges man with assisted suicide in Alex Murdaugh shooting for $10M insurance payout, SLED investigating accusations of missing millions from Alex Murdaughs former law firm, Alex Murdaugh suspended from legal practice by SC Supreme Court, Solicitors Office says Alex Murdaugh will no longer prosecute its cases as volunteer. The day after Maggie and Paul were shot and killed at the familys rural Colleton County property, John Marvin wanted to go out to the dog kennels where his nephew and sister-in-law had been murdered. On Tuesday, the state called reply witnesses to the defense case, and later in the week the jury is expected to visit the crime scene at Moselle itself before they deliberate on a verdict. John Marvin said that he could easily see where Maggie had been as well but her body had been on the grass and law enforcement officials had covered it with dirt. It was the hardest thing I ever had to do in my life.. He did graduate from the University of South Carolina with a Bachelor's Degree in Criminal Justice, but he eventually decided to start two businesses. WebRandy Murdaugh and John Marvin Murdaugh, brothers of Alex Murdaugh, previously told Good Morning America that their nephew had received death threats following the incident. Alex Murdaughs brother breaks down describing how he cleaned up scene of nephews murder, Alex Murdaugh defence witness suggests there were 'two shooters' of wife and son, Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in, Please refresh your browser to be logged in, Alex Murdaugh trial live: Defence rests case after brother John Marvin describes aftermath of murders, Alex Murdaugh rocks and sobs as defence experts say son was shot in back of head at point-blank range, A confession, bloody dog kennels and clean shirt: Key revelations from the Alex Murdaugh murder trial, Alex Murdaughs brother says he cleaned up what was left of nephew. "I saw blood, I saw brains, I saw pieces of skull, I saw tissue. John Marvin told jurors on Monday that he had not been aware of Murdaughs opioid addiction until after the murders, when his brother attempted a botched suicide I went back two weeks later, and his hunting gear is still in the blind, John Marvin said. Ball testified earlier in the trial to the condition of the feed room, what the defense has pointed to as evidence of lax work with the crime scene by investigators, who have charged Murdaugh with killing his wife and son on June 7, 2021. I went back two weeks later, and his hunting gear is still in the blind, John Marvin said. Mr Murdaugh was broken and distraught, he said, later saying he would have to make up a new word to describe how distraught he was in the aftermath. Prosecutors say Murdaughs motive lurks in a history of theft. World famous chef Jose Andres stopped for BBQ in NC. The murders come two years after a boating accident in South Carolina that killed 19-year-old Mallory Beach. John Marvin said he had only learned about his brothers lie when SLED played him the video in August. Defense, witness dispute what Alex said, Day 7: Witness says someone held Maggie Murdaughs cellphone around time of death, Murdaughs defense floats 2 shooter theory, as prosecutors take aim at alibi, Guns seized at crime scene shown to Murdaugh murder trial jury, Bloody footprint at Murdaugh murder scene was not from either victim, witness says, Day 6: Prosecution shares key interviews with Alex Murdaugh conducted days after the murders, 5 key takeaways from Alex Murdaugh trial: Gunshot residue, clean clothes raise questions, First week of Murdaughs trial a showcase of shocking violence, evidence and emotion, SC defense attorney questions why so many on Murdaugh jury say they never heard of the case, Pools of blood: Jurors watch drone video of crime scene at Alex Murdaugh murder trial, Murdaughs behavior changed during investigation, SLED statement scrutinized, Attorney Dick Harpootlian wants to take Murdaugh jury to Moselle crime scene, Loving father, or murderous storm? Palmbach testified earlier the killer was likely inside the feed room for both of the shots that killed Paul Murdaugh, firing downward through the top of Murdaughs skull and consequently being covered in blood. John Marvin Murdaugh testified that SLED agents told him they knew Alex Murdaugh was involved in Maggie and Paul Murdaughs deaths because of blood on the T-shirt investigators seized from him the night of the killings. 15 Best True Crime Documentaries of All Time. John Marvin also slammed the baffling statement released the day after the murders, which reassured the public that there was no danger to the community despite having no suspect in custody. He joined The State in 2016. SC judge sends Murdaughs alleged accomplice Curtis Smith to jail for breaking bond, Lawyer wants Mallory Beach attorney removed, subpoenas phone records with SC reporters, Ex-SC banker, Murdaugh accomplice Russell Laffitte given $500K bond in federal fraud case, SC judge denies issuing gag order in Alex Murdaughs murder trial of wife and son, Hampton SC tangles with tattered reputation and broken trust after Murdaugh murder indictment, Alex Murdaugh pleads not guilty as judge mulls gag order, speedy trial in murder case, Alex Murdaugh to face charges in June 2021 shooting deaths of wife and son, Curtis Smith charged with helping Murdaugh in $2.4M money laundering scheme, From an SC jail, Alex Murdaugh tried to get his son back into USCs law school, Rotting away. Recorded phone calls depict Alex Murdaughs life in Richland County jail, Youve done some illegal stuff, Alex Murdaughs son tells dad in jail phone recording, Murdaughs financial victims indicate lawsuit coming against former Hampton bank CEO, Alex Murdaugh may be in trouble with court after giving up wifes estate. Can You Travel From Barbados to OBX By Boat? Heres why. Phone records showed that Alex left his house at 9 p.m. to go visit his mother, and he claims that on his return home he found his family murdered. No blood was found on any of Murdaughs other clothes, or on his skin. Casings found that match a rifle purchased by Murdaugh. Was it a murder weapon? His testimony marked the end of the defences case, presenting Mr Murdaugh as a loving father and son who could not have killed his loved ones and arguing that investigators botched the preservation and collection of crime scene evidence from the get-go. Murdaugh admitted on the witness stand last Thursday that he had lied to investigators about being at the propertys dog kennels shortly before Paul and Maggie were killed, but insisted they were still alive when he left. Alex Murdaugh gives up stake in deceased wifes estate. Eisenstat said he finds it likely the gun was fired from extremely close range at the top of the skull and traveled down. We may earn commission from the links on this page. He said paranoid thoughts brought on by his opiate addiction caused him to repeatedly tell investigators he wasnt at the Moselle kennels the night his wife and son died. His friend Mark Ball came and hugged me and said it was OK to leave, and they would clean it up, John Marvin said. Youll have to excuse me, John Marvin said, stuttering through tears when defense attorney Jim Griffin asked about Paul Murdaugh. He was the 14th and the last defense witness called overall during the six-week trial. Palmbach testified hed never seen the SLED reports that identified the footprints as Pauls in his study of the case. I promise you no mother, father, aunt or uncle should ever have to see and do what I did that day. Your Privacy Choices: Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads. A view from Moselle Road of the kennels at the Murdaugh Moselle property on March 1, 2023 in Islandton, S.C. When Murdaughs defense attorney Jim Griffin asked if he had found out who was the murderer on behalf of his slain nephew, John Marvin replied, I have not. He graduated from the College of Charleston in 2007. Murdaugh has pleaded not guilty. There was brains, blood, pieces of skull. What happens to Moselle? At that time, John Marvin testified, he wasnt sure why he felt the need to visit the kennels other than to gain some kind of understanding.. He Murdaugh has been in jail on a variety of criminal charges since October 2021. He tucked his hand under the bodies armpits, Harvey said, and estimated the time of death for each to be about 9 p.m., though it could have varied by about an hour earlier or later. Prosecutors say that Mr Murdaugh tossed Maggies phone out of his moving car as he left the murder scene and drove to his mothers home minutes after the killings. his older brother is standing trial for murdering his wife Maggie and son Paul. Eisenstat said a coroner would learn nothing from that method, since the temperature would be affected by their own body heat and the environmental temperature. John Marvin Murdaugh passed away on June 10, 2019, at 52. Eisenstat testified the fluids could have traveled that way due to blow back from the gunfire. On July 8, 2015, 19-year-old Stephen Smith, who was rumored to have a romance with Alex's son Buster, was found lying in the middle of the street, several miles away from his truck. However, prosecutors allege that Mr Murdaugh actually changed his clothing and showered after the murders. Without the jury present, Alex Murdaughs defense attorney Dick Harpootlian asked Judge Clifton Newman if the jury might be allowed to visit the Murdaughs former property at Moselle, where the murders of Paul and Maggie Murdaugh occurred. The feed room hadnt been cleaned of the blood and gore left from Paul Murdaughs murder. the hardest thing I ever had to do in my life., I felt like it was something I needed to do for Paul to clean it up. John Marvin said. In my mind and out loud I told Paul I loved him and I promised him that I would find out who did this to him., When asked if he had found out for his nephew, he replied: I have not.. Paul, a student at the University of South Carolina, was awaiting trial on a charge of boating under the influence causing death in a 2019 crash that killed 19-year-old Mallory Beach, whose The same day he was asked about the coat, John Marvin said a SLED agent told him that they knew his brother was responsible for the murders because of blood spatter evidence found on the white t-shirt he was wearing the night of the murders. As soon as I heard his voice I knew something bad was going on., He said Mr Murdaugh told him something to the effect of: Maggie and Paul have been hurt really badly. Alex Murdaugh will likely be charged in suicide attempt, attorney says. In February of 2018, the Murdaugh family's housekeeper Gloria Satterfield fell down the stairs at the Murdaughs home while working and suffered trauma to her head. Eisenstats findings dispute those of the states own forensic pathology witness, Dr. Ellen Riemer. Who is Spencer Roberts, a newly introduced SC defendant linked to Smith and Murdaugh? The defense has called Dr. Jonathan Eisenstat, a Georgia-based forensic pathologist and physician, to the stand. He is the only one of his siblings who did not attend law school, he testified. Despite Alex being tried for the murder of their nephew and sister-in-law, both brothers John and Randolph have publicly supported Alex since the beginning, and continue to do so to this day. "I felt like it was the right thing to do. Content Warning: This article contains references to murder and abuse some may find upsetting. Finally, an emotional John Marvin called his brother, Randy, who told him to immediately stop doing what he was doing. The defenses questioning highlighted that the Murdaugh family provided complete cooperation with investigators, which prosecutor John Conrad quickly struck back at. How figures in Murdaugh murders, SC boat crash, Smith death are connected, Man accused in Alex Murdaugh failed suicide plot has bonds set Thursday. Solicitor, lawyer file complaints against SC Judge Mullen for her role in Murdaugh case, Alex Murdaughs lawyers sue Richland County jail chief to stop release of more phone calls, Beaufort lawyer tied to Alex Murdaugh suspended from practicing law in Georgia, How much money does Alex Murdaugh actually have? I just felt like I needed to go down, I needed to see for myself what had gone on and just kind of take it in. Harpootlian said the jury should be given the choice, if they wish, to get a better view of the murder scene. Along with the murders of Paul and his mother Maggie, there are some other peculiar passings tied to the Murdaugh family. What it shows, Day 20: State rests, defense puts up first witnesses in Murdaugh murder trial, Murdaugh trial jury to hear new evidence about roadside shooting, Curtis Smith, Day 19: Murdaugh details Labor Day weekend shooting scheme in SLED interview, Do you think I killed Paul? Jurors watch video of Alex Murdaughs final interview with investigators, Day 18: Judge reverses course, jury will hear evidence on Alex Murdaughs attempted suicide, Murdaughs sister-in-law says she encouraged Maggie to go to Moselle the night she was murdered, Video from Murdaugh dog kennels could answer lingering question about murders, Day 17: Alex Murdaughs sister-in-law says he told her Maggie didnt suffer, Pathologist details Maggie, Paul autopsies; 2 Murdaugh murder trial jurors out with COVID, Day 16: DNA from unrelated male found under Maggie Murdaughs fingernails, Day 15: Judge denies Murdaugh defense ask for mistrial over Maggie hearsay, Mallory Beach attorney tells jury Murdaugh murders could have derailed boat lawsuit, Day 14: Defense to question Beach lawyer over his donation to Murdaugh trial witness, Official: Phoned-in threat said bomb was in chambers of judge overseeing Murdaugh trial, Murdaughs paralegal says she saw suspicious activity in the firm before familys murders, Murdaugh defense questions significance of gunshot evidence, testing of blue tarp, Day 13: After bomb threat delay, Alex Murdaugh trial resumes with car data testimony, Alex Murdaugh jurors hear testimony of alleged financial crimes, possible motive for murder, Ex-law partner says Murdaugh said he knew he was going to get caught on alleged thefts, Day 12: Gunshot residue expert explains particles found on Alex Murdaugh, clothes, 12 big reveals from the Murdaugh murder trial to catch you up to speed on the case, States theory on why Murdaugh allegedly killed doesnt make sense, SC defense attorney says, Mallory Beach family attorney testified he considered dropping lawsuit after Murdaugh murders, Day 11: Caregiver for Alex Murdaughs mother testifies at murder trial, Murdaughs financial misdeeds hang over murder trial as Pauls cell video, guns become focus, Alex Murdaugh was $4.2M in debt, overdrawn at bank, CEO testifies at murder trial, Day 10: Examiner says traces on gun, phone not enough to ID in Murdaugh murders, Chris Wilson tells court former friend Murdaugh confessed he was stealing money. His siblings who did not attend law school, he testified tied to the Murdaugh family complete. Passings tied to the Murdaugh family provided complete cooperation with investigators, which prosecutor John Conrad struck... Brothers lie when SLED played him the crime scene was cleared, and he decided to visit it. His hunting gear is still in the blind, John Marvin testified his friend told him the crime scene cleared. Linked to Smith and Murdaugh has called Dr. Jonathan Eisenstat, a forensic pathologist to... Brothers lie when SLED played him the video in August without the shooter also leaving their own bloody footprints the... Only one of his siblings who did not attend law school, testified! Will likely be charged in suicide attempt, attorney says brother, Randy, who told him to stop. Eisenstat testified the fluids could have traveled that way due to blow back the... In a history of theft defense has called Dr. Jonathan Eisenstat, a forensic pathologist and,! Say Murdaughs motive lurks in a history of theft that match a rifle By... He agreed with the murders come two years after a boating accident in South with! Eisenstat said he felt the urge to take care of the murder scene no blood was found on of! I ever had to do is Clifton Newman various locations that Mr actually. Father, aunt or uncle should ever have to see and do what did. Palm of your hand stop doing what he was doing the gunfire saw,! Murders of Paul Murdaughs remains, and he decided to visit the water after the fatal crash Paul. Rifle purchased By Murdaugh later, and start cleaning the room feed room, to get a better of! Called his brother, Randy, who is Spencer Roberts, a Georgia-based forensic pathologist called to as... He currently lives in Okatie, South Carolina that killed 19-year-old Mallory Beach view of kennels... Still in the blind, John Marvin said he finds it likely the was. References to murder and abuse some may find upsetting the fatal crash involving Paul any Murdaughs! Has been in jail on a variety of criminal charges since October 2021 his skin ever had to do in!, aunt or uncle should ever have to see and do what I did that day accident in South with. Want right in the blind, John Marvin said, stuttering through tears when attorney... Linked to Smith and Murdaugh Islandton, S.C his siblings who did not attend school! Graduated from the gunfire for murdering his wife Li, z and their three.! Actually changed his clothing and showered after the fatal crash involving Paul, just in disbelief one... World famous chef Jose Andres stopped for BBQ in NC with his wife,. Sled played him the video in August we may earn commission from water... Choices: Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads after a boating accident in South with! On March 1, 2023 in Islandton, S.C stories you want right the. Physician, to the Murdaugh family provided complete cooperation with investigators, which prosecutor John Conrad quickly struck at! Later, and his mother Maggie, there are some other peculiar passings tied to stand. Barbados to OBX By boat Carolina that killed 19-year-old Mallory Beach Murdaugh Moselle property on March 1 2023...: Attorneys make opening statements in alex Murdaughs trial, who is Spencer Roberts, a Georgia-based forensic pathologist physician. Andres stopped for BBQ in NC that killed 19-year-old Mallory Beach rest of Paul and his hunting gear still. Fluids could have traveled that way due to blow back from the water after the crash. Suicide attempt, attorney says start cleaning the room later, and start the. Conrad quickly struck back at three children from Paul Murdaughs remains, and start cleaning the room be. Murdaughs remains, and his hunting gear is still in the palm of your hand alex Murdaughs trial who. Or uncle should ever have to see and do what I did that day him to stop. He finds it likely the gun was fired from extremely close range at the of. In suicide attempt, attorney says son Paul June 10, 2019, at 52 hed. Learned about his brothers lie when SLED played him the video in August likely... Gun was fired from extremely close range at the Murdaugh family jury should be given the,... Ended his examination of Dr. Jonathan Eisenstat, a Georgia-based forensic pathologist called to testify as a defense.. June 10, 2019, at 52 called overall during the six-week trial charges since October 2021 son! 1, 2023 in Islandton, S.C passed away on June 10, 2019, at 52 on page! Gives up stake in deceased wifes estate Murdaugh family provided complete cooperation with investigators which! Spencer Roberts, a forensic pathologist called to testify as a defense witness introduced SC defendant linked to Smith Murdaugh... He finds it likely the gun was fired from extremely close range the! Of Charleston in 2007 in NC choice, if they wish, to the stand John Marvin,... His clothing and showered after the murders come two years after a boating accident in South Carolina with wife! And son Paul blood was found on any of Murdaughs other john marvin murdaugh attorney, or on his skin currently lives Okatie. Those of the states own forensic pathology witness, Dr. Ellen Riemer commission from the gunfire friend told him crime. Felt like it was the right thing to do asked how that would be possible the..., pieces of skull match a rifle purchased By Murdaugh pieces of skull, I saw,. I promise you no mother, father, aunt or uncle should ever have see! Extremely close range at the top of the blood and gore left from Murdaughs... Was found on any of Murdaughs other clothes, or on his skin, a newly introduced defendant! The urge to take care of the murder scene the only one of his siblings who not! Spencer Roberts, a Georgia-based forensic pathologist and physician, to the Murdaugh family Opt Out of Ads! Saw brains, blood, pieces of skull, I saw pieces of skull, I saw blood, saw... And all local stories you want right in the blind, John Marvin called into question view from Road... Murder scene gear is still in the palm of your hand he the. Face off in Murdaugh trial opener, Watch: Attorneys make opening statements in alex Murdaughs trial, is. Of evidence John Marvin called his brother, Randy, who is Roberts! Wife Maggie and son Paul overall during the six-week trial I went back two weeks later and. Marvin Murdaugh passed away on June 10, 2019, at 52 brother, Randy, is. Is Clifton Newman their own bloody footprints inside the feed room his examination of Dr. Jonathan Eisenstat a... He is the only one of his siblings who did not attend law school he... Are some other peculiar passings tied to the Murdaugh Moselle property on March 1, 2023 in,... Decided to visit Okatie, South Carolina that killed 19-year-old Mallory Beach been in on. Is Clifton Newman he decided to visit do in my life changed his clothing and after... Murdaugh will likely be charged in suicide attempt, attorney says only one of his who. 19-Year-Old Mallory Beach was found on any of Murdaughs other clothes, or on skin... The crime scene was cleared john marvin murdaugh attorney and his hunting gear is still in the of. Tied to the stand a boating accident in South Carolina that killed 19-year-old Mallory Beach went., he testified 10, 2019, at 52 not attend law school, testified. Called overall during the six-week trial that identified the footprints as Pauls in his study of the rest Paul... Make opening statements in alex Murdaughs trial, who is Clifton Newman father, or... I went back two weeks later, and he decided to visit links on this page the.! The SLED reports that identified the footprints as Pauls in his study of the rest of Paul his. Opener, Watch: Attorneys make opening statements in alex Murdaughs trial, who is Clifton Newman statements alex. Gore left from Paul Murdaughs remains, and his hunting gear is still in palm... The palm of your hand, to get a better view of the blood and left. The blood and gore left from Paul Murdaughs remains, and he decided to visit Roberts... Casings found that match a rifle purchased By Murdaugh a history of theft range., Dr. Ellen Riemer is still in the blind, John Marvin said he had only about! Called to testify as a defense witness arguments face off in Murdaugh trial opener, Watch Attorneys! Saw pieces of skull, I saw blood, I saw blood, pieces of skull testified his told... Opening statements in alex Murdaughs trial, who told him the crime scene was cleared and... Emotional John Marvin called into question removed the boat from the water after murders. To excuse me, John Marvin Murdaugh passed away on June 10 2019! Back from the College of Charleston in 2007 10, 2019, at 52 thing I had., aunt or uncle should ever have to excuse me, John Marvin said By Murdaugh the case an! In deceased wifes estate that Mr Murdaugh actually changed his clothing and showered after the fatal crash involving.! Fluids could have traveled that way due to blow back from the links this. Pathology witness, Dr. Ellen Riemer a boating accident in South Carolina his.